1. That first cold September night
You were the blanket holding me tight
You were kissing me and the Earth stood still
You said we don't have to, I said I will, yeah
We ran in when the thunder came
You told me sugar melts in the rain
Don't want to watch our love go to waste
So we ran inside 'fore it was too late.

Oh I, Oh I, I'm not even trying
Oh I, Oh I, but I can't stop smiling, yeah.

[Chorus:]
Do you think about me
Like I think about you
Do you think about me
Like I think about you, yeah?

2. I moved on to another town
Wrote you letters 'til the ink ran out
When the clouds rolled in I grabbed the keys
And played that song that we used to sing
I met a boy a lot like you
It's funny how he used to sing it, too
But he was always just a little out of key
So much different than you and me.

Oh I, Oh I, I'm not even trying
Oh I, Oh I, but I can't stop smiling, yeah.

[Bridge:]
Sometimes I wonder if you wonder
What it could have been like
When you're sitting there drinking coffee
Are you thinking of me
When it's thundering and raining outside?

Oh I, oh I, I'm not even trying
Oh I, oh I, but I can't stop smiling
Oh I, oh I, it's sending me flying
Oh I, oh I, but I can't stop smiling, Yeah.

[Outro:]
Do you think about me
Like I think about you?
Do you think about me?